tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20543146.post6994509884092492798..comments2023-10-18T10:49:11.392-04:00Comments on American Idol Addicts: American Idol 2010 - Top 11 Perform Billboard #1 hits, Miley Cyrus "Mentors"Mike V.http://www.blogger.com/profile/07952930766822976058noreply@blogger.comBlogger5125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20543146.post-32879760292302592482010-03-24T17:50:51.955-04:002010-03-24T17:50:51.955-04:00LOL, glad we're all on the same "PAIGE&qu...LOL, glad we're all on the same "PAIGE" with PAIGE....good times! <br /><br />Vic - I'll try to capture some more quotes as we move on. Once the show gets down to an Hour, I'll have a little more time to work on it. But right now with it going up against LOST, it's killing me! <br /><br />Ian, very interesting with the Aaron pick...we'll see!Mike V.https://www.blogger.com/profile/07952930766822976058noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20543146.post-4931161300586531522010-03-24T14:08:32.436-04:002010-03-24T14:08:32.436-04:00Best of the night for me was Big Mike.
Solid:
Bow...Best of the night for me was Big Mike.<br /><br />Solid:<br />Bowersox - Wasnt as wowed as much as the judges were, but solid.<br />Siobhan - Lose the scream please.<br />Casey - Yeah it was a copy of the original, but a pretty damn good one.<br />Aaron - Could have been the best of the night if he didnt have voice issues.<br /><br />Lacking but not horrible:<br />Katie<br />Didi<br />Andrew<br />Lee<br /><br />Downright horrible<br />Urban<br /><br />Worst performance in Idol history:<br />Paige <br /><br /><br />William WeykoolAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20543146.post-68401918390892820472010-03-24T01:59:49.160-04:002010-03-24T01:59:49.160-04:00I referred to Siobhan as "Bhanny" on my ...I referred to Siobhan as "Bhanny" on my blog. It's not funny, but it is a nickname. I didn't think Paige was as bad as everyone else seems to, but I'll agree she was bad. I picked Aaron as a somewhat surprising elimination.Ianhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05881613487139006347noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20543146.post-25400659766678721832010-03-24T00:37:41.437-04:002010-03-24T00:37:41.437-04:00Hey MikeV...Maybe we should have a list of some of...Hey MikeV...Maybe we should have a list of some of the greatest lines from each episode:<br /><br />My nominees:<br />Best line of the night goes to Casey: "I'm a big fan of - your dad." Ha Ha. That seriously made me LMAO!<br /><br />"The former idols have had 261 Billboard #1s". That doesn't sound right. Is it?<br /><br />Ellen saying that Aaron was just in 3rd grade. LOL Ellen has really picked up her game of late and I think her comedic talent is serioulsy warranted this year more than ever with this group of mediocres.<br /><br />Can we go on record and admit that this season is T-H-E worst Idol season E-V-E-R???? And tonight may very well be the worst night ever. Maybe Miley wasn't such a great "mentor"---their word, not mine----after all. ANd can somebody get the girl some slacks or something??? Geesh!<br /><br />Vic E.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-20543146.post-78248202632195447092010-03-24T00:22:21.335-04:002010-03-24T00:22:21.335-04:00Lee - “The Letter” - Probably his best performance...Lee - “The Letter” - Probably his best performance, but didn't compare to Carly Smithson/Michael Johns. Don't these people watch this show? Never do a song that's already been done successfully by another contestant. That being said, his voice is better than I thought it was.<br /><br />Paige - Against All Odds - Holy hell. No words. After checking the Thesaurus, there are no words capable of describing the suckitude that was Paige butchering this song.<br /><br />Aaron - I don’t want to Miss a Thing - Rascal Flatts will be drafting him into service. Ryan called him David Archuleta and it fits. The tweens will be all over this.<br /><br />Tim - Crazy Little Thing Called Love - And once again, poor Freddie is spinning like a top in his grave. Vocals were fine but where the hell is the heart? Karaoke at it's finest.<br /><br />Crystal - Me and Bobby McGee - GOOSEBUMPS!!! She took on Janis and she was better. And I say that as someone who actually saw Janis in person, have every one of her recordings on LP, CD, and reel-to-reel. If she doesn't win this thing there is no justice in the world. I will be buying the full version asap. Got in 20 votes before Ryan finished the number recap again.<br /><br />Mike - When a Man Loves a Woman - Does his best soul/R&B imitation. Very safe choice as it's a great song but done passably. Simon is right - he should have sung it straight. He's got a good enough voice, he doesn't need all the riff, riff, riff.<br /><br />Andrew - Heard it Through the Grapevine - All I could think of were the singing raisins. Not sure that's what he was going for. Geezuz, if Tim wins the karaoke contest, Andrew takes home the cruise ship mirror ball.<br /><br />Katie - Big Girls Don't Cry - Well, the little girl finally found herself a song. Perfect. I have loathed this girl from week one, but this was a very good performance. She had fun, the song was perfect, and good for her all the way around.<br /><br />Casey - The Power of Love - Probably his best vocal, but still lacks the performance skills. This kid should be in a band - I just don't think he's a solo artist. But in a band - he could sell some records. And Ellen has lost her mind after all the suckitude - calls it the best vocal of the night.<br /><br />Didi - You're No Good - Welcome back, Megan Joy! By the way, we haven't missed you - we have Didi. Please take her home with you. kthxbai Seriously, those who love Didi's quirkiness probably liked this, but not for me at all.<br /><br />Siobhan, aka "Screech" - Superstition - Oh dear. The stylists have gone wild with the crazy girl. (Sorry, the "different, crazy" thing is starting to grate) Credit where it's due, she modernized the song. Good version done well. Did not care for the skatting or screaming at the end. At. All. And Simon agrees with me.<br /><br />Bottom 3 - Paige, Paige, Paige<br /><br />Should go - PAIGE<br /><br />Wish would go - PAIGE<br /><br />Will go - PAIGE <br /><br /><br />John FristAnonymousnoreply@blogger.com